Two 1911 columns looked back to 1895 recaptures at Troy and Tobacco Plains
The Libby Herald’s retrospective column preserves brief references to a person called Whitney. The original 1895 issues and the court outcome have not been verified.
The Libby Herald’s August 17 and September 7, 1911 retrospective columns recall older reports of a person called Whitney being recaptured at Troy and in Tobacco Plains. Their sixteen-year framing points to 1895. The exact event days, full identity and final court outcome have not been established from the original files.
The documented record
- Recorded outcome
- Historical report—outcome unverified
- Archive record date
- Aug 17, 1911
- Location
- Troy / Tobacco Plains / Kalispell
- Court / record
- Kalispell detention and regional captures described retrospectively; court not verified
- Reported event period
- Circa 1895, recalled in 1911 retrospective columns; exact event days not established
This is the outcome documented by the linked material. The timeline and source list distinguish event, decision and publication dates. This entry does not establish current custody, a complete docket or later developments.
Case timeline
- Troy recollection published
The retrospective column recalls a Whitney horse-theft allegation and recapture at Troy.
- Tobacco Plains recollection published
The retrospective column recalls a recapture near the border by Deputy Ramsdell.
The August 17, 1911 Libby Herald, page 5, includes a column headed Sixteen Years Ago This Week. Its subtitle identifies the material as items taken from the old Troy Times. That framing matters: these are recollections of earlier reporting, not a new arrest announcement in 1911.
The Troy reference
One item says a person identified only as Whitney, charged with horse theft, had escaped from the Kalispell jail and was captured at Troy. The paper says Sheriff Baldwin was notified. It supplies neither a full name nor a court case reference.
The sixteen-year interval points back to 1895. It does not establish a precise August day for the arrest. This archive dates the inspected source to August 17, 1911 and describes the older event period separately, rather than inventing a complete 1895 date.
A second recollection in September
On September 7, 1911, page 5, the same retrospective column reports another capture of someone called young Whitney. It says he had twice escaped from the Kalispell jail and was apprehended near the United States boundary in Tobacco Plains by Deputy Ramsdell.
The surname and sequence make the items useful research companions. They are not enough to attach a modern identity record, assert a full biography or prove that every later reference to that surname concerns the same person.
What this preserves—and what it does not
The two inspected pages document how a Libby newspaper remembered earlier regional law-enforcement activity. They support the named places and the allegations as the column reported them. They do not establish a conviction for horse theft, the reason for every detention or a final sentence.
The next research step is to locate the corresponding Troy Times issues and the relevant Kalispell court or jail record. Until those sources are checked, this remains an explicitly dated retrospective record of circa-1895 events, with the legal outcome unverified.
Sources & further reading
Published by Libby.news, a Novus Mercatura product. Produced with Codex from the linked source material; no field reporting or interviews are implied. Our publishing process. Reuse this article.
Information reflects the sources checked for this edition. Follow the linked agencies for changing conditions. Questions or corrections: jesse@libby.news.