Libby, Montana
libby.news

News with a paper trail.Libby · Lincoln County, MT

Crime & courts / News

Restitution award in a Lincoln County benefits case sent back for a hearing

Trey Miller’s July 2026 appeal concerned proof of a $13,938 loss. The court reversed the award and ordered a new restitution hearing, without overturning the guilty pleas.

The short version

The Montana Supreme Court reversed a $13,938 restitution award against Trey Miller on July 28, 2026 and sent the issue back for a new hearing. It found the state had not supplied the sworn evidence required to establish the claimed loss. The decision addressed restitution, not the underlying guilty pleas.

The documented record

Recorded outcome
Restitution reversed; remanded
Archive record date
Jul 28, 2026
Location
Lincoln County
Court / record
Montana Supreme Court; Nineteenth Judicial District Court, Lincoln County
Case reference
DA 25-0370; Lincoln County DC-24-77

This is the outcome documented by the linked material. The timeline and source list distinguish event, decision and publication dates. This entry does not establish current custody, a complete docket or later developments.

Case timeline

  1. Charges filed

    The opinion records felony theft and false-claims charges.

  2. Guilty pleas accepted

    The district court adjudicated Miller guilty of both felonies.

  3. Sentencing

    The court imposed two consecutive five-year deferred sentences and $13,938 restitution.

  4. Restitution appeal

    The restitution award was reversed and sent back for rehearing.

A Lincoln County restitution award was returned to district court for a new hearing after the Montana Supreme Court found the state had not properly established the claimed financial loss. The July 28, 2026 decision in State v. Trey Miller reversed the portion of the judgment requiring payment of $13,938 to Montana’s Unemployment Insurance Division.

The ruling is about the evidence supporting a financial award. It does not say that Miller was acquitted or that his guilty pleas were withdrawn.

How the restitution issue arose

The opinion records that Miller pleaded guilty to felony theft and felony false claims to public agencies. The case involved pandemic unemployment assistance. The district court accepted the pleas on January 27, 2025.

At the March 24, 2025 sentencing, the court imposed two consecutive five-year deferred sentences and the $13,938 restitution award. A deferred sentence is the disposition reported in the opinion; describing it as a ten-year prison term would change its meaning.

The appeal challenged how the state proved the amount of loss. The Supreme Court said the record did not include the required sworn affidavit or testimony from the claimant. An investigation report was not a substitute for that evidence.

The limited result

The court ordered another hearing on restitution, where the district court would have to require evidence consistent with the statute discussed in the opinion. It did not decide that the state’s loss was zero or rule that no restitution could ever be ordered.

This is why a case archive should retain both the original judgment and the later appellate result. Recording only the initial dollar figure leaves out the decision requiring it to be reconsidered. Recording only a reversal, without its limited scope, could wrongly imply that the convictions disappeared.

Find the correct case

The appeal is DA 25-0370, arising from Lincoln County DC-24-77. The opinion is a noncitable memorandum decision, 2026 MT 174N: it documents this case’s disposition and does not serve as precedent.

The Lincoln County Clerk of District Court maintains the local record. A later restitution order would be a separate document to obtain and report; this account does not invent the result of the ordered hearing.

Questions, answered

Did the Supreme Court determine the state lost no money?

No. It held that the claimed amount had not been established through the required sworn evidence and ordered a new restitution hearing. It did not set the final loss at zero.

Sources & further reading

  1. State v. Trey Miller, 2026 MT 174N, DA 25-0370Montana Supreme Court · 2026-07-28
  2. Clerk of the District Court: public records and accessLincoln County

Published by Libby.news, a Novus Mercatura product. Produced with Codex from the linked source material; no field reporting or interviews are implied. Our publishing process. Reuse this article.

Information reflects the sources checked for this edition. Follow the linked agencies for changing conditions. Questions or corrections: jesse@libby.news.

Comments

Keep it relevant to the story. Leave your nickname blank to appear as Anonymous. Comments are reviewed before they appear.

0 / 5,000 characters

Quick addition check