Libby, Montana
libby.news

News with a paper trail.Libby · Lincoln County, MT

Crime & courts / Explainer

Two 1911 reports trace a Libby altercation from arrest to a bond hearing

The Libby Herald’s later account includes Frank Gagnon’s self-defense position and a $300 bond. A final verdict has not been verified.

The short version

The Libby Herald reported a nonfatal knife altercation near Mineral Avenue and Second in November 1911, followed by Frank Gagnon’s surrender. Its November 16 follow-up says he argued self-defense and was held to answer with $300 bond. Neither inspected report supplies a final verdict or sentence.

The documented record

Recorded outcome
Historical report—outcome unverified
Archive record date
Nov 16, 1911
Location
Libby
Court / record
Judge Hoffman’s local court, as reported; docket not identified
Reported event period
November 1911; record date is the November 16 hearing report

This is the outcome documented by the linked material. The timeline and source list distinguish event, decision and publication dates. This entry does not establish current custody, a complete docket or later developments.

Case timeline

  1. Initial report published

    The Herald describes the alleged altercation, surrender and postponed hearing.

  2. Hearing report published

    The Herald reports a self-defense position, a hold-to-answer decision and $300 bond.

A local brief in The Libby Herald, November 9, 1911, page 5, and a front-page follow-up one week later preserve different stages of the same Libby case. Reading them together adds a defense account that the initial item does not contain.

The first report

Under the heading Cutting Fracas, the paper described a knife altercation near Mineral Avenue and Second. It named Frank Gagnon as the accused, reported nonfatal injuries to another man and said Gagnon went to the jail building, surrendered and was detained.

The report also said the hearing had been postponed because the injured man could not appear. This entry omits his identity and the newspaper’s graphic injury descriptions. The relevant documentary point is that the first account preceded a completed hearing.

The following week’s account

On November 16, page 1, the Herald included Gagnon in an article headed Two Bound Over. It said Judge Hoffman had heard the matter, that Gagnon put forward self-defense, and that he was held to answer with bond fixed at $300.

The report does not say the court accepted or rejected the self-defense position as the final resolution. Being held to answer and having bond set are the developments this source establishes as reported. They should not be rewritten as a conviction.

Why both sources belong in the record

The first story supplies the reported location and arrest sequence. The second adds the defense position and the court’s reported response. Neither includes a docket number, a full hearing transcript or an eventual judgment.

The archive date is November 16, the verified follow-up publication date. The original pages remain the primary reading links, preserving the difference between the initial allegation and the later procedural account. No final disposition has been independently verified for this entry.

Sources & further reading

  1. The Libby Herald, November 9, 1911, page 5: Cutting FracasThe Libby Herald; Montana Historical Society / Library of Congress · 1911-11-09
  2. The Libby Herald, November 16, 1911, page 1: Two Bound Over, Gagnon paragraphThe Libby Herald; Montana Historical Society / Library of Congress · 1911-11-16

Published by Libby.news, a Novus Mercatura product. Produced with Codex from the linked source material; no field reporting or interviews are implied. Our publishing process. Reuse this article.

Information reflects the sources checked for this edition. Follow the linked agencies for changing conditions. Questions or corrections: jesse@libby.news.

Comments

Keep it relevant to the story. Leave your nickname blank to appear as Anonymous. Comments are reviewed before they appear.

0 / 5,000 characters

Quick addition check